SWING TRADE PERFORMANCE vs IBD
How does Above the Green Line (ATGL) Swing Trader compare to Investor’s Business Daily (IBD) Swing Trader? Its very simple, Above the Green Line Swing Trading Performance versus IBD Swing Trader is the better choice. See for yourself. The metrics for ATGL Swing Trading Performance versus IBD Swing Trader are updated on a quarterly basis.
- Above the Green Line Average Profit per Trade is greater 8 out of last 9 years.
- Cost: Above the Green Line is $45 monthly compared with IBD @ $69 monthly.
- Total Trades: Approximately EVEN.
- Profit / Trade: Above the Green Line is 2.19% / Trade compared with IBD 0.38% / Trade.
- Winning Percent: Above the Green Line is 52.43% compared with IBD 47.86%.
Below is a comparison between Above the Green Line and Investor Business Daily (IBD) Swing Trader over the past 8 years ending 12/31/2024.
The results from the past eight years highlight a significant contrast between ATGL Swing Trading and IBD Swing Trading. While both approaches have delivered varied performances, ATGL demonstrates consistent advantages in profitability and win percentages. Across all years, ATGL achieved a total profit percentage of 2.19%, significantly outperforming IBD’s 0.38%. Furthermore, ATGL maintained a higher overall win rate at 52.43% compared to IBD’s 47.86%.
In specific years, ATGL excelled notably, such as in 2020 when it achieved a profit percentage of 6.51% and a win rate of 62.50%, outperforming IBD’s 1.21% profit and 55.86% win rate. Conversely, in isolated cases like 2017, IBD delivered better results with a higher profit percentage (0.81% versus ATGL’s 0.03%) and win rate (57.50% versus 46.32%).
ATGL also demonstrated resilience and outperformed in challenging markets. For instance, in 2023, ATGL posted a 2.19% profit despite market volatility, whereas IBD recorded a loss of -0.13%. This consistent edge underscores ATGL’s ability to deliver stronger returns, making it a compelling choice for swing traders aiming for higher profitability and more consistent winning trades.
Below is a comparison of Above the Green Line’s Top Pick of Week Strategy versus IBD and traditional swing trading.
