Above the Green Line -01
  • Market Insights
        • Commentary
          • Daily
          • Weekly
        • BUY / SELL SIGNALS
          • Trade Posts
          • Recent Trade Alerts
          • Recent Day Trades
        • BLOGROLL
          • Dividend Growth Blog
          • ETF Sector Blog
          • Dow Dogs
          • TPOW Blog
  • Strategies
        • SWING TRADING
          • Current Positions
          • Watchlists
          • Closed Positions
          • Candidates - TOP 100
          • Specialty Stocks
        • WEEKLY STOCK PICK
          • TPOW Charts
          • TPOW Performance
          • TPOW Strategy Guide
          • TPOW Performance Dashboard
        • DAY TRADING
          • Watch List
        • ATGL DASHBOARD
        • ETF STRATEGIES
          • ETF Sector Rotation
          • ETF Sector Portfolio
        • DIVIDEND GROWTH
          • Dividend Growth Portfolio
          • Dividend Calendar
        • DOGS OF THE DOW
          • Dogs of the Dow Portfolio
          • DOW 5 Portfolio
  • Markets
        • US MARKET
          • Commodities
          • Energy
          • Precious Metals
          • Volatility
        • GLOBAL MARKETS
          • Market Indices
          • Economic Calendar
          • FOREX Heat Map
          • FOREX Cross Rates
          • Crypto Currency Market
  • Investing
    • Discord Community
    • Dashboard
  • Resources
        • ARTICLES
          • Dividend Growth Model Articles
          • ETF Articles
          • Investment Strategies Articles
          • Market and Economic Insights
          • Stock Trade Articles
          • Stock Reviews
        • TOOLS
          • Stock Scanners
          • Charting Software
          • Brokerage Firms
        • STOCK CHARTS
          • Key Components
          • Reading Charts
          • Drawing Stock Charts
          • Identifying Trends
        • RETIREMENT PLANNING
  • About
    • Contact Us
    • How to Win
    • #1 At Stockcharts
    • Disclaimer
    • FAQ
  • Log In
  • Subscribe

November 22, 2019

Buy and Hold vs. Market Timing

Buy and Hold Investing or Market Timing?

By Author

Updated February 8, 2024

Table of Contents

Toggle
  • Buy and Hold Investing or Market Timing?
      • Market Timing
      • Buy and Hold Investing
      • Key Takeaways

There is often debate between investors as to which investment method is better: a traditional buy-and-hold approach or market timing. Here, we will discuss the merits and challenges that both strategies present to hopefully give a better understanding of which method works best for you.

Market Timing

Market timing is a strategy that is highly debated as its methodology involves great risk and effort. In short, market timing is the ability to predict the market’s short term reversal points, meaning the right points in time to enter and exit the market. Since it is a short term approach, it requires a great deal of diligence as well as ample time to give to monitoring the market. Why participate in a high-risk scenario that requires a great deal of attention? Well, there is a potential for a high return. Over the past decade, the S&P 500’s annual average return is 9.10%. This is the average return that investors would experience using a more long term strategy. In contrast, those who use the methodology of market timing correctly can outperform this return greatly, thus gaining more profit in a shorter amount of time. For example, the chart below represents a sample taken over 63 years of the “best five trading days”; a strategy that outperforms the market’s annual return a total of forty-two times. However, this is an incredibly difficult game to play. Returns are often concentrated in a very short time span and the chances of receiving no returns or even worse, negative returns, are dangerously high considering no one can predict the future with complete accuracy. It is important to weigh the risks and benefits before engaging with market timing.

Chart showing the sums of the best five trading days according to the S&P 500

Buy and Hold Investing

Buy-and-hold investing, also known as passive management, varies greatly from market timing. Instead of predicting the right points to enter and exit the market, an investor employing a buy-and-hold approach selects securities or funds and then holds onto them long term with no focus on short term price fluctuations. It is generally thought that when employing this method one’s assets should not be needed for three to five years. Many investors are advocates of this method simply because it works. Since the buy-and-hold strategy is based entirely on fundamental analysis, there is no room for subjectivity. Forecasting the degree of growth, however, is subjective. The chart below illustrates this concept well as the probability of negative returns decreases greatly as time goes on. The benefits of a buy-and-hold strategy sound enticing; it requires little effort and over time will guarantee somewhat of a return. Nonetheless, it is important to note that there are consequences for utilizing this strategy. As previously discussed, a buy-and-hold strategy requires a significant time investment and it is up to the investor’s discretion just how long they would like to hold on. It is essential to know that one cannot expect a degree of return that matches the time invested. For instance, if an investor were to hold on to a stock for ten years, that does not guarantee it will represent the magnitude of time they spent without that asset. Lastly, there is always the possibility of a market crash. During a crash, buy-and-hold investors can lose most if not all of their gains. It is necessary to consider the pros and cons of a buy-and-hold strategy before participating in it.

Chart descirbing the relationship between time and probability of negative return

Key Takeaways

In short, an investor utilizing a buy-and-hold strategy would buy and hold onto securities for the long term. The interpretation of the magnitude of ‘the long term’ varies between investors. Employing market timing involves buying and selling over a short term period in hopes of profiting from price swings. A buy-and-hold strategy tends to be a more secure path, while market timing is generally a more difficult approach. At the end of the day, both methods have their pros and cons; it all depends on the investor themselves and what best suits their needs.

Related Articles

Calendar Spread Options

Calendar Spreads for Options Traders: Setup, Risks, and Rewards

Options allow you to express a view on direction, volatility, and time. Spreads refine that view by balancing cost and ...
Read More
Liquidity Risk

Why Liquidity Risk Matters for Your Trades – Especially in Volatile Markets

When markets accelerate, getting in or out at a fair price can matter more than your thesis. Liquidity risk is ...
Read More
Capital Growth

A Modern Guide to Capital Growth Management for Traders and Investors

Capital growth management is the disciplined process of expanding principal over time while keeping risk aligned to your objectives. You ...
Read More
Dark Pools

What Are Dark Pools in the Stock Market? A Trader’s Guide

The modern stock market operates through multiple layers of complexity, where institutional investors execute massive orders that could significantly impact ...
Read More
Volume Profile Indicator

How to Use the Volume Profile Indicator for Price-Level Precision

Precision in market timing separates successful traders from those who struggle with inconsistent results. While price action provides valuable insights, ...
Read More
Gamma Squeeze

How a Gamma Squeeze Works and How to Spot One on a Chart

Unusual market events can trigger dramatic price movements that create significant opportunities for prepared investors. A gamma squeeze stands out ...
Read More

ON ATGL

  • DashBoard
  • Weekly Commentary
  • Daily Buy / Sell Signals
  • Day Trade Setup
  • Trading Rooms

Design & Develop By Pixelvect

STRATEGIES

  • Swing Trading
  • ATGL Pick of the Week
  • Dividend Growth
  • ETF Sector Rotation
  • Dogs of the Dow

HELP

  • ATGL Trading Rules
  • FAQ
  • Account Maintenance
  • Contact US
  • Join

FOLLOW US

Instagram Linkedin Twitter Facebook

© COPYRIGHT 2024 · ABOVETHEGREENLINE.COM · ALL RIGHTS RESERVED · PRIVACY · TERMS · CONTACT · WATCHLIST · CURRENT